We construct for the first time smooth circle actions on highly symmetric manifolds such as disks, spheres, and Euclidean spaces which contain two points with the same isotropy subgroup whose representations determined on the tangent spaces at the two points are not isomorphic to each other. This allows us to answer negatively a question of Hsiang and Hsiang [Some Problems in Differentiable Transformation Groups, Springer, Berlin, Problem 16, p. 228, 1968].