Development of minimally invasive techniques to collect nutritional information from free-living birds is desirable for both ethical and conservation reasons. Here, we explore the utility of waterfowl eggshell membranes to determine the nutrient source of egg formation by using stable isotope ratios. We compared δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N of membranes from complete king eider (Somateria spectabilis) eggs to membranes of hatched or depredated eggs of the same clutch remaining after incubation. Despite large variation among membranes (δ¹³C: −26 to −14‰) we found a highly predictable relationship between δ¹³C of complete egg membranes and remaining (hatched or depredated) membranes from the same clutch. We did not find a consistent change in either δ¹³C or δ¹⁵N of eggshell membranes during incubation. We suggest that isotope ratios of membranes can be used to determine the source of exogenous nutrients for egg production in income breeders, and that membranes may offer a clutch-specific reference point for dietary nutrients (‘income endpoint’) in isotopic mixing models quantifying nutrient allocation in capital or mixed-strategy breeders.