Western classical music was long distinctive among the arts for its universality and catholicity. From Greek antiquity on,
music uniquely reflected Orphic, mystic, celestial feeling, And unlike painting, architecture, or literature, the standard
musical canon came to be breathtakingly inclusive over time as well as space. Yet in recent centuries music has increasingly
celebrated national patriotism and period particularism. This essay traces the histories of these antithetical expressive
urges, the one universalistic, transcendental, atemporal, the other chauvinist, parochial, historicist.
Keywords heritage - nationalism - particularism - universalism - Western music
This essay was initially conceived as a keynote talk for ‘‘The Tuning of the World’’, an acoustic ecology conference at the
Banff Centre for the Arts, Alberta, Canada, in August 1993 in honor of R. Murray Schafer. To him, to Georgina Boyes, Ruth
Finnegan, Lily Kong, Jessie Owens, and, in memoriam, to Aldo Ghisalbert and Malcolm Macdonald, I am grateful for generous
inspiration