Natural resonance theory (NRT) and nucleus- independent chemical shift (NICS) analyses have been applied to the standard nucleobases
adenine, guanine, cytosine, uracil, and thymine. The molecular electron densities were obtained from density functional theory
calculations at the B3LYP level and ab initio calculations at the HF, MP2, and CCD levels. Compared with the dominance of
the two Kekulé structures in benzene, the structural modifications in the forms of endocyclic heteroatoms and exocyclic substituents
introduce various degrees of charge separation in nucleobases. As a result, the leading resonance structures for cytosine,
uracil, and thymine are found to be covalent structures, but their weightings decrease to ~30% in the NRT expansion. For adenine
and guanine, the covalent structures have weightings of ~20%, and the leading ionic resonance structures have weightings of
as high as about 8%. Methods that include electron correlation effects, B3LYP, MP2, and CCD, give smaller weightings for the
covalent structures than HF. However, MP2 and CCD results often include “strange” resonance structures with connections between
unbonded vicinal atoms, making DFT at the B3LYP level the better choice for calculating these molecules’ electron density.
The NICS at the ring center shows that the six-membered rings in cytosine, uracil, thymine, and guanine are nonaromatic with
NICS within − 3 to − 1 ppm, while it is − 7.3 ppm for the six-membered ring in adenine. The NICS of the five-membered rings
of adenine and guanine is around − 12 ppm, a slight decrease from the value of − 15.0 ppm for pyrrole.
Keywords Nucleobase - DFT - Natural bond orbital - Natural resonance theory - Quantum chemical calculations - Aromaticity - Nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS)