OBJECTIVE: We compared the reproducibility and accuracy of conventional clinical examination of the diabetic foot to monofilament examination.
We also sought to simplify the monofilament examination by reducing it to fewer touch points.
METHODS: In a cross-sectional study at 10 centers in the United States, Canada, and Switzerland, general internists and residents
performed a structured history and physical examination for neuropathy on the feet of diabetic patients. Independent examination
by two observers included monofilament sensation, pinprick, vibration, position sense, and ankle reflexes.
MAIN RESULTS: A total of 304 patients were examined by at least one practitioner, and 200 received duplicate examinations. Monofilament
examination and ankle reflexes had the best reproducibility, with moderate agreement (κ=0.59); pinprick, position, and vibration
sense had fair agreement (κ=0.28–0.36). No component of the history or physical examination, singly or in aggregate, was both
sensitive and specific for identifying a patient with an abnormal monofilament examination. A simplified monofilament examination
using only 4 sites per foot (total 8 sites) detected 90% of patients with an abnormal 16-site monofilament evaluation.
CONCLUSIONS: Conventional clinical examination had low reproducibility and correlated poorly with monofilament examination for the identification
of the at-risk patient. The Semmes-Weinstein monofilament examination, a reproduible, valid, and generalizable test of foot
sensation, is recommended as the screening procedure of choice for examining diabetic feet.
Dr. Edelman is supported by a VA Health Services Research Career Development Award.
The International Cooperative Group for Clinical Examination Research included the following site coordinators and participating
centers: Durham Vetrans Affairs Center, Durham, NC (David Edelman, David Simel); Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma, Wash
(Jeff Jackson); Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Fla (Mark Parkulo); McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont, Canada (Marek Smieja, Dereck
Hunt, Jim Nishikawa, Herzel Gerstein, Rose Hatala); Minneapolis Veterans Affairs Hospital, Minneapolis, Minn (Craig Roth);
San Antonio Veterans Affairs Hospital, San Antonio, Tex (John Williams); Universite de Lausanne, Switzerland (Jacques Cornuz,
Maria Gueorguiev); University of Kentucky, Lexington, Ky (Don Holleman); University of Texas, San Antonio, Tex (Pat Wathen,
Bob Badgett); University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, Tex (Jim Wagner); University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont, Canada (Ed
Etchells); and University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wis (Mae Hla).