| Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research |
| © The Association of Bone and Joint Surgeons 2008 |
| 10.1007/s11999-008-0439-5 |
| (1) | Orthopaedics and Trauma, Khoula Hospital, PO Box 3007, Ruwi, 112 Muscat, Sultanate of Oman |
![]() |
Wahid Al-Kharusi Email: wahidk@omantel.net.om |
Received: 12 January 2008 Accepted: 18 July 2008 Published online: 14 August 2008
|
UN resolutions ON road safety |
Date of the resolution |
Resolution number |
|---|---|---|
|
1st UN resolution |
March 2003 |
57/3007 |
|
2nd UN resolution |
September 2003 |
58/9 |
|
3rd UN resolution |
April 2004 |
58/289 |
|
4th UN resolution |
October 2005 |
A/60/L8 |
|
2003 |
1. Endorsed WHD 2004—7th April. 2. Approved UN Resolution 57/3007 |
1. Road Safety Is No Accident. 2. Submit to UN The world report on traffic injury prevention. |
|
2004 |
1. Resolution WHA 57.10 2. Endorsement of UN Resolution 58/289 |
1. Road Safety Is A Public Health Problem. 2. WHO to be the Coordinator for UN Road Safety Initiatives. |
|
2007 |
Endorse WHA 60/22 |
Emergency pre-hospital medical care system agenda |
The Middle East is part of West Asia and North Africa; actually the countries of the Eastern Mediterranean Region are very diverse socioculturally, economically, educationally, and politically. Prevention and management of road traffic crashes and injuries is therefore a mammoth task. Comparative data of the various aspects throughout the region are not readily available, thus developing unified policies for the region is daunting. Lack of implementation of best practices in the region is due to the different levels of enforcement of legislation. Furthermore, the lack of provision of holistic trauma care has a direct impact on the outcome of road traffic crashes and injury which is visible due to the sociocultural and economic differences between the countries in the region. Professional staff are scarce and the deficiency must be addressed for any positive development to occur. As a result, management of road traffic crashes needs to be specifically addressed at the country level with regional cooperation.
The Eastern Mediterranean Region has the world’s highest traffic fatality rate among young men aged 15–29 years at 34.2 deaths per 100,000. The deaths are estimated to cost US $7.4 billion annually. Traffic fatalities from the year 2000 to the year 2020 are expected to rise by 68% [10]. Within this region in 2002 the mortality rate due to injury was twice that of the rest of the world [9]. Injuries caused 16% of all deaths [10]. The low- and middle-income countries of the Eastern Mediterranean Region accounted for the second highest mortality rate after Africa. Worldwide mortality from road traffic accidents averages 26.3% per 100,000 people per year. Global and regional records suggest there are 40 million people with disabilities who have limited access to rehabilitation and nearly nonexistent social reintegration.
|
Country |
Number of vehicle |
Number of RTC |
Number of deaths |
Number of injured |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Jordan |
612,330 |
70,266 |
818 |
12,727 |
|
UAE |
1,100,765 |
8,269 |
824 |
10,233 |
|
Tunis |
1,113,493 |
10,880 |
1,656 |
15,698 |
|
Algeria |
4,000,000 |
43,777 |
4,356 |
64,714 |
|
Saudi Arabia |
2,087,769 |
293,281 |
5.168 |
34,811 |
|
Oman |
468,412 |
9,460 |
637 |
6,636 |
|
Palestine |
186,153 |
4,760 |
163 |
4,905 |
|
Qatar |
424,461 |
2,362 |
164 |
1,371 |
|
Lebanon |
4,494 |
397 |
3,227 |
|
|
Yemen |
60,254 |
12,257 |
2,249 |
13,117 |
|
TOTAL |
10,053,637 |
459,806 |
16,432 |
167,439 |
Oman has seen miraculous transformation in the past 38 years since The Renaissance inspired and led by His Majesty Sultan Qaboos bin Said. The Sultanate of Oman is located in the southeastern corner of the Arabian Peninsula, with a coastline extending 1700 km and covering an area approximately 309,500 square km, of which 82% is desert. It is divided into 10 health regions with a population of 3,500,000 (2007 statistics) [6]. It is an autocratic benevolent form of government with a political system involving a Ministerial Cabinet and State Council. The members of Consultative Councils are elected by the people.
The health services are mainly provided by the Ministry of Health, together with the Royal Oman Police and the Royal Army of Oman. Seven years ago, encouragement of the development of the private health sector was initiated, resulting in a very active and successful private health care system today. By Royal decree health and education is afforded free of charge to nationals. For non-national residents, the sponsors are responsible for their health care.
The total budget allocated for the Ministry of Health in 2006 was 202,593,000 Omani Rials (OMR) with a recurrent annual expenditure of 24,145,000 OMR, of which 8,000,000 OMR is used annually for development of their services. There has been an improvement in the number of doctors to the population between 1970 (0.2:10,000) and 2006 (12.6:10,000). While the number of hospital beds per doctor in 1970 was 0.9, in 2006 it was 1.4 [4].
A number of studies are annually performed for planning purposes ranging from school health programs to clinic health service studies. The geographic distribution of MOH institutions as of Dec 31st 2006 in the 10 health regions is 199 health institutions with a population per hospital bed of 567 patients. There are 30 government hospitals and a number of health facilities with various health provisions with a total number of hospital beds of 4549 [4].
Hospital deaths in MOH hospitals have increased from 2,042 in 1995, to 3,027 in 2006. This is attributed to the increase in population. Inpatient morbidity in MOH institutions due to external causes in 2006 was 17,205, of which road traffic crashes and injury victims comprised 5217 patients, 891 of whom were between the ages 1–14 years. This indicates that the morbidity due to road traffic crashes is a third of the total number of morbidity due to external causes. This is quite high and needs to be reduced and brought under control [4].
|
1936 |
Oman Traffic Code |
|
1982 |
Road Traffic Awareness Committee |
|
1986 |
Helmet Laws |
|
1990 |
Safety Belt Laws |
|
1993 |
1. Royal Decree For EMS Formation. 2. First Ever Countrywide survey on road traffic crashes. |
|
1997 |
Higher Committee For Road Safety- Royal Decree 97/64 –1997 |
|
1998 |
Children Traffic Village |
|
2000 |
Mobile Phone Laws and Mobile Radars |
|
2004 |
Road Safety College. Fixed Radars countrywide. |
|
2004 |
Launching of Ambulance EMS Service |
|
2006 |
Vehicle Registration and Road Worthiness Centers |
In Oman, as in other countries, there are challenges to overcome such as program responsibility, inadequate specialized manpower, sociocultural issues such as fatalism and macho attitudes, the ever-increasing need for funding, lack of comprehensive data, deficiencies in the undergraduate curriculum in injury and trauma management and lack of research. Most aspects of these challenges have been addressed such as development of a comprehensive trauma register, an EMS system, modern regional hospitals supported by a level one trauma center, advocacy and awareness programs, introduction of road safety issues in school curriculum, and working towards development of a national action plan to include a youth council. A number of Royal Decrees across the board have been issued to empower national bodies to implement changes involving road safety. Currently, even with these measures, Oman road traffic crashes are fluctuating in number and in the extent of physical injuries to the victims. We need to do more to achieve acceptable results (Table 4).
At the onset we must bear in mind that it takes a generation from the onset of change to realize tangible, positive results. At the beginning, we will undoubtedly continue to experience increases in road traffic crashes and injuries especially with the growth in motorization and industrialization (Europe’s experience in the sixties and seventies). We must ask ourselves how we can successfully and methodically challenge this pandemic in the EMRO region, and what is required for implementation of these changes. Short- and long-term action plans need to be implemented. We do not need to reinvent the wheel. The WHO World Report and its six recommendations and the UNECE transportation guidelines and regulations for road safety are an excellent starting point. The best practices recommended by WHO again are applicable globally and their implementation is the key to success. We all have similar regional needs. Practical and successful experiences in diverse countries of the region can be shared and applied from one country to another with some modifications considering their various socio-economic status, population density and developmental process.
We need to identify our needs and requirements at a national level. At the onset we urgently need to identify the extent of the problem and the impact of road traffic crashes and injuries in our individual countries of the region. We have to accept and appreciate the impact these crashes have on the victims of road traffic crashes and their families, especially the children. Injury prevention requires aggressive advocacy, adequate funding for education and research, and effective intervention programs. The criterion of this management is that a problem cannot be solved until it is defined in its magnitude and scope. We need to realize that one cannot change something until one can manage it. We need to define measurements to monitor the impact and effectiveness of intervention. This can occur through community-based preventive programs.
A registry should be established that would be comprehensive in the sense that it not only provides statistics of the numbers of crashes but also furnishes the end users with the individual details of each crash. It is important that the registry should highlight the economic damage of the crash after including all direct and indirect costs incurred, as this aspect of the crash attracts the decision-makers. This can then be used as an advocacy tool for the decision-makers and those responsible for developing and implementing policies related to road safety. Oman has initiated a trauma registry based on this concept. At present it is in its final stages of development. The concept of the trauma register is to combine a number of sectors on which the crash has an impact, including police reports, health services, social services for the disabled, orphans and widows, the courts, and insurance companies. Each section of the registry will enlighten us regarding the actual types of damage incurred. The final product will give us a holistic insight into the crash and allow us to extrapolate data to enhance road safety in all aspects, providing tools for the policy makers to increase the political will and funding. This registry is electronic and the questionnaire can also be manual. The concept is that it is hospital- and community-based and it is multisectoral. Thus, it will identify the burden of disease and the socioeconomic, psychological, and medico-legal implications of the crashes and injuries and, most importantly, the final health status of the victim and his/her family. The registry will follow through the victim from the site of injury through prehospital care, complete trauma care, rehabilitation and social integration, police report, social services report and finally the courts and insurance report. We are recommending this registry be managed by the Physical Medicine Departments of different hospitals, which can accumulate data from the patients treated in their hospitals. The information can be transmitted to the Department of Statistics and Data Collection in the Ministry of Health as they have contact with the victims and their families long after their acute management ceases. Once this is in place, long-term planning can be easily achieved. Meanwhile we need to start implementing what is urgently required.
The region is very short of professional personnel in road safety, so capacity building is a priority. Furthermore, we need to have communication between the countries of the region and have knowledge sharing and transfer. We need to implement best practices by implementing and enforcing whatever legislation is endorsed by the country and ensuring consolidation of regional cooperation. This will improve the crash statistics. We need to not only decrease the number of crashes but also dramatically improve and limit the extent of the physical and psychological damage to the victims and their families. We must realize at the onset it will be difficult but not impossible to realize. Despite lack of funding and political involvement, by implementing the trauma registry we will raise awareness of the social and national burden incurred by road traffic crashes.
What we urgently need to address is the provision of the holistic approach to trauma care. This is another major problem in our region. Usually prehospital management is either lacking or rudimentary in most of these countries. At the same time, rehabilitation is also very limited and does not specialize in spinal and head injury patients as needed. Social reintegration for all does not exist in most of the countries of the region. The end result is that many disabled patients are unfortunately left in the care of relatives at home with little to no followup. As a result the victims never regain their independence and their self-respect as they cannot even care for themselves, let alone their families.
Education, training, capacity building and research are other concepts of road safety that are extremely lacking. We need to identify potential skilled workers and provide proper training facilities, currently missing due to a lack of funding and proficiency. Population-based surveys or studies directed at decision-makers are not available. These types of surveys are crucial to get the policy and decision-maker to take action and to develop intervention and surveillance policies and funding for the intervention.
The region is facing a number of challenges. This is due to lack of diversity, funding, and ownership of the program; lack of specialized manpower; cultural and religious stigmata such as fatalism and rich boy syndrome; lack of community-based preventive programs; deficiency in education in road safety at all tiers including the undergraduate medical programs; absence of holistic approach to trauma care; and finally, we have brain drain of the few specialized personnel which directly affects the sustainability of the program. We also need to identify our limitations within the region, such as limited population-based data to develop preventive strategies and policies, and identification of the responsible sector to record injuries and their outcomes. Whatever few studies or peer-reviewed articles are available do not reach the circles of the decision-makers.
Funding is crucial but grossly lacking. Prioritization of the health issues in the region is one of the major drawbacks. Advocacy of road safety in most of the countries of the region is limited. The availability of practical, evidence-based information to trigger the flow of funds is practically nonexistent. Inclusion of private and cooperate sectors in the countries is not fully utilized. Absence of strong and active NGOs is a gross limitation.
We need to work very closely with the community. The ignorance and lack of awareness within the community with regard to the impact of road traffic crashes and injuries needs to be addressed through community programs, including using the media for education, in school curricula for the promotion of safety awareness in future generations, through religious outlets, and using every opportunity to introduce road safety in our community.
Individual countries need to find a way to force the issue of road safety. We must imprint and impress upon every member of the community that we are collectively responsible for each and every one of us, and especially for the safety of our children whom we not only love and cherish but who are the future of our societies. To achieve these goals, we need to have not only policies but a structured organization in each country that is chaired by a very high-ranking and respected individual with enough authority to gather each concerned sector in road safety, who commands attention, and who has the power to remove challenges and obstacles blocking road safety projects.
For this organization to be effective and to be able to manage road traffic crashes and injury prevention it needs to have: (1) a strategy with clear objectives and senior level commitment; (2) an organizational structure, operating plan and governance; (3) management leadership, focused staff, proper communication, and performance tracking; (4) auditing through monitoring, evaluation and, when necessary, restructuring of the program.
Finally, the region urgently needs to have an educational institution, preferably in the form of a university, specializing in road safety. All the countries of the region must support this institution. The different tracks in education, training and research in road safety management will be available for all. This is the only way we can build up our capacity. The future generations will take over road safety management and, with their different skills, our challenges and limitations will be effectively tackled and minimized. This loss of life and health, especially in young people from our region, is especially unacceptable since it is preventable. We must respond to this growing epidemic. The first response is the creation of a dedicated agency in the country—an institute for road and transportation safety.
| 1. | Browner B. Lecture: Road Traffic Injury – the Neglected Global Epidemic. BJD World Network Conference and Patient Advocacy Seminar. Durban, South Africa; 2006. |
| 2. | Commission for Global Road Safety Web site. Make Roads Safe: A New Priority for Sustainable Development. 2007. Available at: http://www.makeroadssafe.org/documents/make_roads_safe_low_res.pdf. |
| 3. | Global Road Safety Web site. Available at: http://www.globalroadsafety.org/world_response/global_resolutions/index.shtml. |
| 4. | Ministry of Health Web site. Available at: www.moh.gov.om. |
| 5. | Murray CJ, Lopez AD. The Global Burden of Disease: A Comprehensive Assessment of Mortality and Disability from Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors in 1990 and Projected to 2020. Boston, MA: Harvard University, School of Public Health; 1996. |
| 6. | Royal Hospital Web site. Available at: www.royalhospital.med.om. |
| 7. | The Task Force for Child Survival and Development Web site. Rosenberg M. The Global Road Safety Crisis: We Should Do Much More. Available at: http://www.taskforce.org/index.asp. |
| 8. | World Health Organization Web site. Penden M, Ed. World Report on Road Traffic Injury Prevention. Available at: http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/publications/road_traffic/world_report/en/. |
| 9. | World Health Organization/EMRO Web site. WHO/EMRO 2006: Commissioning an Expert Group for Documenting Injury Data in the Eastern Mediterranean Region. Available at: www.emro.who.int/pressreleases/2006/no25.htm. |
| 10. | World Health Organization/EMRO Web site. WHO/EMRO 2006: WHO Regional Survey on National Situation and Response to Violence and Injury. Available at: www.emro.who.int/pressreleases/2006/no25.htm. Accessed January 2008. |