Welcome!
To use the personalized features of this site, please log in or register.
If you have forgotten your username or password, we can help.
|
 |
An Evaluation of Vernal Pool Creation Projects in New England: Project Documentation from 1991–2000
| |
|
Environmental Assessment
An Evaluation of Vernal Pool Creation Projects in New England: Project Documentation from 1991–2000
Lesley E. Lichko1 and Aram J. K. Calhoun1  | (1) | Department of Plant, Soil, and Environmental Sciences, University of Maine, 5722 Deering Hall, Orono, ME 04469, USA |
Published online: 21 August 2003 Abstract Vernal pools are vulnerable to loss through development and agricultural and forestry practices owing to their isolation from open water bodies and their small size. Some vernal pool-dependent species are already listed in New England as Endangered, Threatened, or Species of Special Concern. Vernal pool creation is becoming more common in compensatory mitigation as open water ponds, in general, may be easier to create than wooded wetlands. However, research on vernal pool creation is limited. A recent National Research Council study (2001) cites vernal pools as  challenging to recreate.  We reviewed documentation on 15 vernal pool creation projects in New England that were required by federal regulatory action. Our purpose was to determine whether vernal pool creation for compensatory mitigation in New England replaced key vernal pool functions by assessing project goals and documentation (including mitigation plans, pool design criteria, monitoring protocols, and performance standards). Our results indicate that creation attempts often fail to replicate lost pool functions. Pool design specifications are often based on conjecture rather than on reference wetlands or created pools that function successfully. Project monitoring lacks consistency and reliability, and record keeping by regulatory agencies is inadequate. Strengthening of protection of isolated wetlands in general, and standardization across all aspects of vernal pool creation, is needed to ensure success and to promote conservation of the long-term landscape functions of vernal pools. Keywords Vernal pool - Wetland creation - Compensatory mitigation - Wetland monitoring - Reference wetlands - New England
References
| Alford, R. A., Richards, S. J. (1999) "Global amphibian declines: a problem in applied ecology." Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 30: 133-165 |
| |
| Antonelli, J. J. (1997) "The use of shallow groundwater wells to obtain hydrologic data for wetland delineation." Wetland Journal 9: 3-7 |
| |
| Babbitt, K. J., Tanner, K. W. (2000) "Use of temporary wetlands by anurans in a hydrologically modified landscape." Wetlands 20: 313-322 |
| |
| Berven, K. A., Grudzien, T. A. (1990) "Dispersal in the wood frog (Rana sylvatica): Implications for genetic population structure." Evolution 44: 2047-2056 |
| |
| Bonner, L. A., Diehl, W. J., Altig, R. (1997) "Physical, chemical and biological dynamics of five temporary dystrophic forest pools in central Mississippi." Hydrobiologia 353: 77-89 |
| |
| Breaux, A., Serefiddin, R. (1999) "Validity of performance criteria and a tentative model for regulatory use in compensatory wetland mitigation permitting." Environmental Management 24: 327-336 |
| |
| Brinson, M. M., Rheinhardt, R. (1996) "The role of reference wetlands in functional assessment and mitigation." Ecological Applications 6: 69-76 |
| |
| Brooks, R. T., Stone, J., Lyons, P. (1998) "An inventory of seasonal forest ponds on the Quabbin Reservoir watershed, Massachusetts." Northeastern Naturalist 5: 219-230 |
| |
| Brown, S., Veneman, P. (1998) Compensatory wetland mitigation in Massachusetts, Massachusetts Agricultural Experiment Station, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA |
| |
| Butterwick, M. (1996)
"The hydrogeomorphic approach and its use in vernal pool functional assessment." In: Witham, C. W.,
Bauder, E. T.,
Belk, D.,
Ferren, W. R.,
Jr., Ornduff, R. eds. , Ecology, conservation, and management of vernal pool ecosystems. Proceeding from a 1996 Conference, California Native Plant Society, Sacramento, CA, pp 50-55 |
| |
| Calhoun, A. J. K., and M. W. Klemens. 2002. Best development practices for conserving pool-breeding amphibians. Wildlife Conservation Society Technical Paper #5. Wildlife Conservation Society, Rye, New York |
| |
| Calhoun, A. J. K., Hunter, M. L. (2003)
"Managing ecosystems for amphibian populations." In: Semlitsch, R. D. eds. , Amphibian conservation., Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C., pp 228-241 |
| |
| Calhoun, A. J. K., Walls, T., McCollough, M., Stockwell, S. (2003) "Developing conservation strategies for vernal pools: a Maine case study." Wetlands 23: 70-81 |
| |
| Carey, C., Cohen, N., Rollins-Smith, L. (1999) "Amphibian declines: an immunological perspective." Developmental and Comparative Immunology 23: 459-472 |
| |
| De Weese, J. 2000. Vernal pool construction monitoring protocol and habitat replacement evaluation: Pacific region. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. (URL: www.rl.fws.gov/es/vpfinal.html) |
| |
| Dodd, C. K., Jr., Cade, B. S. (1998) "Movement patterns and the conservation of amphibians breeding in small, temporary wetlands." Conservation Biology 12: 331-339 |
| |
| Duellman, W. E., Trueb, L. (1986) Biology of amphibians, McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York |
| |
| Ernst, C. H., Barbour, R. W. (1989) Snakes of eastern North America, George Mason University Press, Fairfax, Va |
| |
| Fagan, W. F. (1999) "Weak influences of initial conditions on metapopulation persistence times." Ecological Applications 9: 1430-1438 |
| |
| Fretwell, J. D., J. S. Williams, and P. J. Redman (eds.) 1996. National water summary on wetland resources. USGS Water Supply Paper 2425, USGS Information Services, Denver, CO |
| |
| Galatowitsch, S. M., van der Valk, A. G. (1996) "Characteristics of recently restored wetlands in the prairie pothole region." Wetlands 16: 75-83 |
| |
| Gibbs, J. P. (2000) "Wetland loss and biodiversity conservation." Conservation Biology 14: 314-317 |
| |
| Hanski, I., Gilpin, M. E. (1991) "Metapopulation dynamics: Brief history and conceptual domain." Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 42: 3-16 |
| |
| Joyal, L. A., McCollough, M., Hunter, M. L., Jr. (2001) "Landscape ecology approaches to wetland species conservation: a case study of two turtle species in southern Maine." Conservation Biology 15: 1755-1762 |
| |
| Kusler, J. A. 2001. The SWANCC decision and state regulation of wetlands. Association of State Wetland Managers, Inc. (url: http://www.aswm.org/swancc/aswm-int.pdf) |
| |
| Kusler, J. A., Kentula, M. E. (1990)
"Executive summary." In: Kusler, J. A.,
Kentula, M. E. eds. , Wetland creation and restoration: the status of the science, Island Press, Washington, D.C., pp xvii-xxv |
| |
Lannoo, M., Lang, J. K., Waltz, T., Phillips, G. S. (1994) "An altered amphibian assemblage: Dickenson County, Iowa, 70 years after Frank Blanchard s survey." American Midland Naturalist 131: 311-319 |
| |
| Lubow, B. C. (1996) "Optimal translocation strategies for enhancing stochastic metapopulation viability." Ecological Applications 6: 1268-1280 |
| |
| Marsh, D. M., Trenham, P. C. (2001) "Metapopulation dynamics and amphibian conservation." Conservation Biology 15: 40-49 |
| |
| Mitsch, W. J., Wilson, R. F. (1996) "Improving the success of wetland creation and restoration with know-how, time, and self-design." Ecological Applications 6: 77-83 |
| |
| Mitsch, W. J., Wu, X., Nairn, R. W., Weihe, P. E., Wang, N., Deal, R., Boucher, C. E. (1998) "Creating and restoring wetlands." BioScience 48: 1019-1030 |
| |
| National Research Council (2001) Compensating for wetland losses under the Clean Water Act, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., pp 322 |
| |
| National Wetlands Policy Forum (1988) Protecting Americans wetlands: an action agenda, Conservation Foundation, Washington, D.C., pp 69 |
| |
| Pechmann, J. H. K., Wilbur, H. M. (1994) "Putting declining amphibian populations in perspective: natural fluctuations and human impacts." Herpetologica 50: 65-84 |
| |
| Pechmann, J. H. K., Estes, R. A., Scott, D. E., Gibbons, J. W. (2001) "Amphibian colonization and use of ponds created for trial mitigation of wetland loss." Wetlands 21: 93-111 |
| |
| Pope, S. E., Fahrig, L., Merriam, H. G. (2000) "Landscape complementation and metapopulation effects on leopard frog populations." Ecology 81: 2498-2508 |
| |
| Pough, F. H. (1983)
"Amphibians and reptiles as low-energy systems." In: Aspey, W. P.,
Lustick, S. I. eds. , Behavior energetics: the cost of survival in vertebrates., Ohio State University Press, Columbus, OH, pp 141-188 |
| |
| Preisser, E. L., Kefer, J. Y., Lawrence, J. D., Clark, T. W. (2000) "Vernal pool conservation in Connecticut: an assessment and recommendations." Environmental Management 26: 503-513 |
| |
Richter, K. O. (1997)
"Criteria for the restoration and creation of wetland habitats of lentic-breeding amphibians of the Pacific Northwest." In: Macdonald, K. B.,
Weinmann, F. eds. , Wetland and riparian restoration: Taking a broader view. Contributed papers and selected abstracts, Society for Ecological Restoration, 1995 International Conference, September 14-16, 1995, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA, pp 72-94
Comment: Publication EPA 910-R-97-007. USEPA, Region 10, Seattle, WA |
| |
| Richter, K. O., Azous, A. L. (1995) "Amphibian occurrence and wetland characteristics in the Puget Sound Basin." Wetlands 15: 305-312 |
| |
| Rowe, C. L., Dunson, W. A. (1995) "Impacts of hydroperiod on growth and survival of larval amphibians in temporary ponds of Central Pennsylvania, USA." Oecologia 102: 397-403 |
| |
| Sala, O. E. (2000) "Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100." Science 287: 1770-1774 |
| |
| Semlitsch, R. D. (1998) "Biological delineation of terrestrial buffer zones for pond-breeding salamanders." Conservation Biology 12: 1-8 |
| |
| Semlitsch, R. D. (2002) "Critical elements for biologically based recovery plans of aquatic-breeding amphibians." Conservation Biology 16: 619-629 |
| |
| Semlitsch, R. D., Bodie, J. R. (1998) "Are small, isolated wetlands expendable?" Conservation Biology 12: 1129-1133 |
| |
| Seigel, R. A., Dodd, C. K., Jr. (2002) "Translocations of amphibians: Proven management method or experimental technique?" Conservation Biology 16: 552-553 |
| |
| Snodgrass, J. W., Komoroski, M. J., Bryan, A. L., Jr., Burger, J. (2000) "Relationships among isolated wetland size, hydroperiod, and amphibian species richness: implications for wetland regulations." Conservation Biology 14: 414-419 |
| |
| Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, 2001 WL 15333 (Sup. Ct., 2001) |
| |
| Trenham, P. C., Marsh, D. M. (2002) "Amphibian translocation programs: Reply to Seigel and Dodd." Conservation Biology 16: 555-556 |
| |
| Stone, J. S. 1992. Vernal pools in Massachusetts: Aerial photographic identification, biological and physiographic characteristics, and state certification criteria. Masters Thesis. University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA |
| |
| U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1989. Memorandum of Agreement Between the Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of the Army concerning the determination of mitigation under the Clean Water Act Section 404 (b)(1) Guidelines. Washington, DC |
| |
| U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New England District. April 1, 2002 Checklist for review of mitigation plan with accompanying introduction: performance guidelines and supplemental information on the checklist for review of mitigation plan |
| |
| Wilbur, H. M. (1980) "Complex life cycles." Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 11: 67-93 |
| |
| Windmiller, B. S. 1996. The pond, the forest, and the city: Spotted salamander ecology and conservation in a human-dominated landscape. Ph. D. Dissertation. Tufts University, Medford, MA |
| |
| Winston, R. B. (1997) "Problems associated with reliably designing groundwater-dominated constructed wetlands." Wetland Journal 9: 21-25 |
| |
| Wyman, R. L. (1998) "Experimental assessment of salamanders as predators of detrital food webs: effects on invertebrates, decomposition and the carbon cycle." Biodiversity and Conservation 7: 641-650 |
| |
| Young, B. E., Lips, K. R., Reaser, J. K., Ibanez, R., Salas, A. W., Cedeno, J. R. et al. (2001) "Amphibian conservation in Latin America." Conservation Biology 15: 1213-1223 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|