Volume 8, Number 1, 83-98, DOI: 10.1007/s11948-002-0034-1

Diverse knowledges and competing interests: An essay on socio-technical problem-solving

Vincent di Norcia

View Related Documents

Abstract

Solving complex socio-technical problems, this paper claims, involves diverse knowledges (cognitive diversity), competing interests (social diversity), and pragmatism. To explain this view, this paper first explores two different cases: Canadian pulp and paper mill pollution and siting nuclear reactors in seismically sensitive areas of California. Solving such socio-technically complex problems involves cognitive diversity as well as social diversity and pragmatism. Cognitive diversity requires one to not only recognize relevant knowledges but also to assess their validity. Finally, it is suggested, integrating the resultant set of diverse relevant and valid knowledges determines the parameters of the solution space for the problem.

Keywords  problem-solving - knowledge - expertise - diverse interests - engineering - risk - sociotechnical - pragmatism - pluralism - stakeholders - nuclear reactors - pollution - organochlorines - paper mills - NRC - ethical - complexity

The author is a Professor of Philosophy at The University of Sudbury, Ontario, Canada.

Fulltext Preview

Image of the first page of the fulltext document